You’ve made the decision to update your flooring, and now you’re down to the final choice: vinyl plank vs. hardwood. Both options bring an elegant touch to any room, but which one is better?
Although vinyl and hardwood flooring may appear similar, each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. If you have pets or children and prioritize durability, or if you’re working with a limited budget and want a cost-effective solution, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each to help you choose the best flooring for your home.
This guide examines nine key factors to help you make the smartest flooring decision.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Vinyl Plank | Hardwood | |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | Can rip or tear easily. May dent in spots under heavy furniture or appliances. | Susceptible to scratches, dings, or dents. Hardwoods and engineered woods are tougher than exotic wood types. |
| Waterproof | Yes | No |
| Cleaning | Can be cleaned with no-wax cleaners and maintained by wet mopping, vacuuming, or sweeping with a broom or dust mop. | Must be cleaned with hardwood-specific products. Wet mopping is not advised. |
| Maintenance | Shine can be restored by applying no-wax polish. | Waxing can restore shine, but refinishing may be needed over time. |
| Pet-Friendly | Yes | Yes, but softer woods are more prone to scratches. |
| Styles | Offers various styles that replicate the appearance of real wood. | A wide selection of wood species is available, ranging from classic to exotic options. |
| DIY Installation | Yes | Professional installation is highly recommended. |
| Prone to Fading | Yes, prolonged exposure to sunlight can cause fading. | Can naturally fade over time but maintains a natural look. Refinishing is an option if necessary. |
| Sizes | Widths range from 6 to 9 inches, with lengths up to 60 inches. | Available in widths from 2 to 10 inches and lengths up to 7 feet, with custom sizes also offered. |
| Colors | Comes in a variety of colors, including white,cherry, and ebony. | A broad range of colors is available, and unfinished flooring can be stained to your preference. |
| Comfort & Acoustics | Feels softer and warmer, offering better sound insulation. | Can feel colder and harder underfoot compared to other flooring. |
| Home Resale Value | Generally does not boost resale value as much as hardwood floors. | Considered a premium feature that can enhance a home’s appeal and market value. |
| Environmental Impact | Non-biodegradable, non-recyclable, and may release harmful VOCs. | A more eco-friendly and biodegradable flooring alternative. |
| Flooring Guide | Vinyl Plank Flooring Guide | Hardwood Flooring Guide |
Vinyl Flooring vs. Hardwood Flooring: Comparison Across 9 Factors
- Durability
- Water Resistance
- Color & Style Selection
- Ease of Installation
- Care & Maintenance
- Cost
- Comfort & Acoustics
- Home Resale Value
- Environmental Impact
#1. Durability
Although hardwood flooring can get scratched or damaged, it remains one of the most durable options overall. Still, homeowners with kids or pets—or those who prefer not to deal with the cost of refinishing floors over time—might find vinyl plank flooring to be a better choice.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Highly resistant to scratches, chips, and dings – No need for refinishing, making it cost-effective – Vulnerable to tears if heavy or sharp objects are dropped or dragged – Soft material can dent under heavy furniture or appliances | – Prone to scratches or chips – Durability depends on the wood species – Expensive to repair or refinish, but can last a long time with proper care – Engineered hardwood is sturdier but offers limited refinishing opportunities |
Many parents and pet owners appreciate the beauty of hardwood flooring, but concerns about rough play, sharp claws, and heavy foot traffic often arise. After all, no one wants to spend hundreds or thousands of dollars on floors that could be easily damaged. This is why durability plays such a significant role when comparing hardwoods to vinyl plank flooring.
Vinyl Plank Flooring Durability
Scratches, chips, and dings aren’t a concern with vinyl plank. It doesn’t have to be refinished like hardwoods, which is a big advantage for budget-minded homeowners.
However, vinyl plank isn’t completely immune to damage. Because it is created using soft vinyl, this flooring can tear. Though it isn’t a common occurrence with everyday use, dropping something hard or sharp or dragging furniture or other heavy items can result in rips.
Because it is a soft flooring, it can also be prone to dents. This is especially true in areas underneath heavy furniture and appliances.
Hardwood Flooring Durability
Hardwood flooring can develop scratches over time from pets, people, or furniture being moved. Dropping heavy items can also chip or otherwise damage the surface.
The durability of hardwood depends largely on the wood species. Popular choices like oak, maple, and cherry are known for being tougher, while exotic woods, although visually stunning, are softer and more prone to damage.
Damaged hardwood can be repaired, replaced, or refinished, but these options tend to be costly. With the right care, though, hardwood floors can last for decades and are among the most durable flooring options available.
Engineered hardwood, made with a real wood veneer over layers of plywood or other wood, is another alternative. It’s more durable than solid hardwood but can only be refinished once or twice over its lifespan.
#2. Water Resistance
Since vinyl plank is waterproof, you can install it in any room, making it better than hardwood flooring when it comes to water resistance. Anyone seeking a flooring option for basements, bathrooms, kitchens, or other areas unsuitable for hardwood will be happy with the performance of vinyl planks.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Completely waterproof, resists water damage – Perfect for kitchens, bathrooms, and basements – Safe for areas with frequent spills or wet mopping – Won’t warp, buckle, or be damaged by moisture | – Hardwood floors are easily harmed by water – Avoid wet mops; clean spills immediately Not suitable for rooms with high moisture |
Vinyl Flooring Water Resistance
One of vinyl plank’s best features is that you can get it wet without worrying about damage. Vinyl plank flooring is fully waterproof, making it a top choice for any room.
You can install vinyl planks in any space. It’s perfect for kitchens and bathrooms, where floors might get wet after a bath or washing dishes. It’s also ideal for basements.
Spills from kids or wet mopping won’t ruin vinyl plank flooring. Unlike other hard flooring types, vinyl planks won’t warp, buckle, or get damaged by water or liquids.
Hardwood Flooring Water Resistance
On the other hand, hardwood floors can be damaged by water. Don’t use wet mops, and make sure to clean spills right away. Hardwood isn’t recommended for rooms that deal with moisture buildup.
Exposing hardwood floors to water can ruin them, leading to expensive replacements. In some cases, hardwood can be saved, but the process is time-consuming and should be done by a professional. They can handle the job properly and make sure no harmful mold grows.
#3. Color & Style Selection
Both options offer numerous choices, but hardwood outshines vinyl in terms of available colors and styles.
With an extensive range of wood species, various sizes, and the option to custom stain, hardwood offers greater flexibility than vinyl plank.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Imitates the appearance of hardwood (cherry, oak, exotic woods, etc.) – Advanced printing techniques produce realistic textures and details – Plank sizes: widths from 6″ to over 9″, lengths from 36″ to 60″ – Thickness: 2mm to 4mm+ – Primarily rectangular, though some square options exist | – Multiple wood species: walnut, maple, hickory, ash, birch, pine – Wide selection of colors, finishes, glosses, and textures – Available in both modern and classic styles – Unfinished options for custom staining and color matching – Plank sizes: widths from 2″ to 10″ (with 5-8 inches being most common), lengths from 1 foot to 7 feet – Standard thickness: ¾-inch, with thinner 5/16-inch options for glue-down floors |
Vinyl Flooring Appearance and Customization Options
One reason vinyl plank is becoming more popular is due to its wide variety of styles that replicate the look of hardwoods. From cherry to oak and even exotic cedar, manufacturers are constantly introducing new vinyl flooring products that look more realistic than ever before.
Modern printing technologies add fine details to each vinyl plank. With different patterns and unique textures, the planks can closely resemble real wood floors, both in appearance and feel.
Vinyl Plank Sizes
Vinyl plank comes in many sizes. Typical widths range from 6 inches to over 9 inches, with lengths from 36 inches to about 60 inches. The thickness of vinyl planks varies between 2 millimeters and over 4 millimeters.
Most vinyl planks are rectangular, similar to other types of flooring such as laminate and hardwoods. However, some manufacturers also create square planks. Vinyl plank comes in a variety of different colors as well, from whitewashed to ebony.
Hardwood Flooring Appearance and Customization Options
Hardwood floors come in numerous species, including walnut, maple, hickory, ash, birch, and pine. (Read our blog on the pros and cons of oak, maple, and hickory here.)
You can buy hardwoods in a variety of colors and finishes, along with different gloss levels and textures. They are available in both modern and traditional designs.
Unfinished hardwood floors are another option for those who prefer a custom color. You can apply a stain to achieve a unique shade that can’t be found anywhere else. This is also an excellent choice for blending new floors with existing wooden floors.
Hardwood Flooring Sizes
Hardwood flooring comes in widths ranging from 2 inches to 10 inches, with 5 to 8 inches being the most common. Plank lengths range from 1 foot to 7 feet.
Most hardwood floor planks are ¾-inch thick. But recently, manufacturers have introduced a thinner, glue-down hardwood option that is about 5/16-inch thick.
#4. Ease of Installation
In this category, vinyl plank stands out as the top choice. It is easy for most people to install with just basic tools, while hardwood flooring requires more equipment, time, and skills.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – There are two types: floating and peel-and-stick – Floating floor: uses tongue-and-groove design, snaps together without nails or glue – Peel-and-stick: peel off the backing and stick it down – Both options are simple for DIY installation and can be cut easily with a utility knife | – Time-consuming and labor-intensive – Needs specialized tools – Requires subfloor preparation and a vapor barrier – Involves measuring, cutting, and nailing – Must allow space for wood to expand and contract – High chance of mistakes leading to damage – Professional installation is often needed, adding to costs |
Vinyl Flooring Installation
There are two types of vinyl plank flooring. Luckily, both are quite simple for homeowners with the right tools and some time to spare.
The first type of vinyl plank is installed as a floating floor. Its tongue-and-groove design allows you to snap the planks together without nails or glue, much like installing laminate flooring. Because the vinyl is soft, it’s easy to cut to size with a utility knife or scissors.
The second type is peel-and-stick vinyl planks, a perfect choice for beginners. Just peel off the backing and stick the planks onto the subfloor. This method is simple, requiring only measuring, aligning, and cutting with a utility knife.
Hardwood Flooring Installation
In contrast, installing hardwood flooring is more challenging. While homeowners can tackle the project, it demands more work from beginning to end. It requires extra tools and can take days or even weeks, while vinyl plank can be installed in just hours.
Hardwood flooring installation starts with preparing the subfloor, which requires time and expertise. A vapor barrier must be installed before the flooring. Then, you must measure, cut with a saw, and nail the boards into place.
When installing hardwood, you also need to consider the wood’s expansion and contraction. Improper measurement or installation can lead to buckling and damage.
Due to the many steps involved and the risk of costly errors, many homeowners prefer to hire professionals for the installation. This adds extra costs, which can be a concern for those on a tight budget.
#5. Care & Maintenance
Overall, vinyl flooring is the simplest to maintain daily. However, hardwood floors are long-lasting and, with the right care, can remain looking fresh for many years.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Low-maintenance choice – Daily cleaning: broom, dust mop, sweeper, vacuum – Deeper cleaning: wet mop – Use vinyl-specific polish to bring back shine – Avoid wax-based cleaners to prevent buildup – Protect from sunlight with rugs, shades, or blinds – Fading is permanent; requires plank replacement if damaged | – Keep floors dry; wipe spills immediately – Keep floors dry; wipe spills right away – No wet mops; only dry cleaning – Sweep or dust mop daily – Use a hardwood-safe vacuum (no beater bar) – Clean with hardwood-specific products for deep cleaning – Wax floors occasionally to restore shine – Expect natural fading and wear over time – Refinish professionally when scratches or wear become noticeable |
Vinyl Plank Flooring Care & Maintenance
Vinyl flooring is a great choice for the low-maintenance household. For daily vinyl plank cleaning, a broom, dust mop, sweeper, or vacuum cleaner can be used to clean up dirt, crumbs, and dust. For deeper cleaning, you can use a wet mop.
To bring back the shine when the floor looks dull, use a vinyl-specific polish. Be sure to choose a cleaner without wax. Vinyl flooring does not require wax, and using wax-based polishes or cleaners can lead to unwanted buildup.
Vinyl can fade over time or when exposed to sunlight. To prevent fading, use rugs in sunlit areas or keep the floors covered with shades and blinds. Once the floor has faded, it can only be restored by replacing the planks.
Hardwood Plank Flooring Care & Maintenance
Hardwood flooring has several special considerations. Because it can’t get wet, you should always immediately wipe spills up. You should never use wet mops on hardwoods.
For daily cleaning, use a broom or dust mop. A vacuum is fine, but ensure it’s a model designed for hardwood floors, without a beater bar that could scratch and damage the surface.
For deeper cleaning, use products specifically made for hardwood floors. Over time, hardwoods may lose their shine and require waxing to restore their luster.
Hardwoods naturally fade over time. Although they can maintain their beauty for many years, heavy foot traffic, scratches, or general wear will eventually show. When that happens, a professional can refinish the floor.
#6. Cost
When shopping for new floors, most buyers have a budget in mind. New floors can be pricey, but which option is more affordable when comparing vinyl plank to hardwood?
It’s clear that vinyl plank is the more budget-friendly choice, providing the stylish look of wood at a much lower cost. However, it’s important to remember that hardwood can last for many years, while vinyl plank often needs to be replaced sooner. In the long run, hardwood might be the better investment.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – $2 to $7 per sq ft – Low overall cost, no extra materials needed – DIY-friendly for added savings – Professional installation: $1 to $4 per sq ft | – Expensive flooring option – Mid-grade woods: ~$5 to $10 per sq. ft. – Exotic woods: ~$15+ per sq. ft. – DIY installation is uncommon; contractor is usually required – Installation cost: additional $5 to $8 per sq. ft. |
Cost of Vinyl Floors
Vinyl plank flooring costs typically range between $2 and $7 per square foot.
This is one of the most affordable flooring choices compared to others. No additional costs are usually added since vapor barriers, nails, and adhesives aren’t needed.
Many people install vinyl tiles themselves, making it a very cost-effective option. However, for those who prefer professional installation, it will usually cost $1 to $4 per square foot.
Cost of Hardwood Floors
Hardwood flooring is one of the priciest types of flooring. Mid-grade woods usually cost about $5 to $10 per square foot, while exotic woods can cost $15 or more per square foot. This is a significant difference compared to vinyl plank.
Since many people don’t have the tools or skills for DIY hardwood installation, they often hire a contractor. This usually adds $5 to $8 per square foot to the overall installation cost.
#7. Comfort & Acoustics
Vinyl flooring feels softer and warmer underfoot and reduces noise better, while hardwood gives a classic look but feels harder and colder.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Soft and cushioned underfoot – Resilient core adds comfort when standing or walking – Acoustic backing cuts down on noise – Ideal for homes with kids or pets | – Hard and cool underfoot – Not as comfortable for long periods of standing – Rugs or padding can improve comfort – Offers a timeless, traditional look – Less warmth and softness than vinyl |
Comfort of Vinyl Flooring
Vinyl flooring, particularly luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring, is great for homeowners who want extra comfort. Its soft surface and resilient core make it more comfortable than hardwood, especially when standing or walking for long periods.
Many vinyl plank options also come with acoustic backing to reduce noise from footsteps and other sounds. This makes vinyl perfect for homes with children or pets because it helps create a quieter, more comfortable home.
Comfort of Hardwood Floors
While hardwood floors are elegant and long-lasting, they can feel hard and cold underfoot, especially in the colder months. Standing for long periods on hardwood can be uncomfortable compared to vinyl’s softer feel.
To make hardwood floors more comfortable, you can add rugs or padding. While hardwood doesn’t offer the same warmth or cushioning as vinyl, it remains a great choice for those who prefer a classic and traditional look.
#8. Home Resale Value
While luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is a practical and low-maintenance choice, hardwood flooring is often more seen as a premium feature that can increase a home’s resale value and appeal.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Popular for waterproof use in kitchens and bathrooms – Doesn’t add much value to a home compared to hardwood – May be seen as lower-end in upscale areas | – Considered a premium feature that boosts value – Homes with hardwood often sell faster and for higher prices – Provides a good return on investment ($4 for every $1 spent) |
Resale Value of Vinyl Plank Flooring
Luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is growing in popularity because it’s durable and waterproof, making it a smart choice for kitchens, bathrooms, and other areas prone to moisture. Buyers who care about functionality and low maintenance are drawn to it.
However, vinyl doesn’t add much resale value, especially in higher-end markets. In neighborhoods where hardwood is the standard, vinyl might be seen as a less desirable option, which can limit its appeal.
Resale Value of Hardwood Flooring
Hardwood flooring is highly valued in real estate. Its long-lasting nature, classic look, and premium reputation help increase a home’s resale value.
Homes with hardwood floors typically sell faster and for more money than homes without them.
Realtors frequently note that hardwood can offer a strong return on investment, with some estimates suggesting a $4 return for every $1 spent. While it costs more upfront, hardwood helps boost a property’s value, making it a smart choice for those looking to increase their home’s market appeal.
#9. Environmental Impact
Hardwood floors, particularly those from sustainably-managed forests, are more eco-friendly and can break down naturally. On the other hand, vinyl flooring has a larger environmental footprint because it is not biodegradable, cannot be recycled, and releases harmful VOCs into the air.
| Vinyl Flooring | Hardwood Flooring |
|---|---|
| – Less eco-friendly than natural options – Made from PVC – Some options use recycled materials – Not biodegradable, not recyclable, and adds to landfill waste – Releases harmful VOCs that lower air quality – Low-VOC choices available (e.g., Floorscore IAQ certified) | – Biodegradable and recyclable – Sustainable when sourced from responsibly managed forests (e.g., FSC certified) – Can impact the environment during harvest and processing – Reclaimed wood and low-VOC finishes improve sustainability |
Environmental Impact of Vinyl Floors
Vinyl flooring is made from PVC, which comes from fossil fuels. Some eco-friendly vinyl options use recycled materials and reduce VOC emissions, but vinyl is still a problem. It doesn’t break down, can’t be recycled, and ends up in landfills.
Also, making vinyl releases VOCs that harm air quality. Choosing products with certifications like Floorscore IAQ can help reduce these emissions, but overall, vinyl is not as sustainable as natural materials.
Environmental Impact of Wood Floors
Wood flooring is more eco-friendly, especially when it comes from responsibly managed forests. Wood is natural, biodegradable, and can be recycled or reused. Hardwood floors from certified sources, such as those with Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification, have a lower environmental impact.
While cutting and processing wood can cause some harm, using responsible methods can reduce these effects. Reclaimed wood and low-VOC finishes further improve the sustainability of hardwood floors.
FAQ
Both vinyl plank and hardwood flooring have their strengths and weaknesses. The better option for you depends on your needs. Hardwood floors are a good investment, raising your home’s value. They are beautiful, long-lasting, and can be refinished or waxed to maintain their look.
Vinyl plank flooring is a tough option that looks like wood and comes in many styles and colors. It is waterproof and more affordable than hardwood. It’s also easier to install, while hardwood often requires professional help.
What is the average cost to install vinyl plank flooring?
Even though vinyl planks are easy to install, many homeowners choose to hire professionals. The cost for installation typically ranges from $1 to $4 per square foot, but this can change based on the method, room size, and the job’s difficulty.
Installation costs can also vary by state, so it’s a good idea to contact different professionals, ask about their prices, and check if any extra fees apply.
Is vinyl plank cheaper than hardwood?
Yes, vinyl plank flooring is generally much less expensive than hardwood. Vinyl planks usually cost between $2 and $7 per square foot, and they don’t require many additional materials, making them cheaper to maintain.
In contrast, hardwood floors are one of the priciest options, especially if you choose exotic wood. The price for hardwood ranges from $5 to $10 per square foot. However, hardwood adds value to your home and can last up to 100 years.
What is a negative of vinyl flooring?
Vinyl floors may release volatile organic compounds (VOCs), have a shorter lifespan compared to wood floors, and may not add value to your home or even hurt its resale value. They can also be difficult to remove, especially if adhesive was used during installation.
Can vinyl plank flooring be installed over engineered hardwood?
While it’s possible to install vinyl planks over many subfloors, you should be careful when putting them on top of engineered hardwood. The bond between the floors might not be strong enough with click or glue-down vinyl.
A floating vinyl floor is a better choice for installation over existing floors. Make sure the subfloors are completely flat before starting.
The Verdict
Both vinyl plank and hardwood floors have advantages and disadvantages. Vinyl plank is the more affordable option and is great for homes with kids or pets, or for those who don’t want to spend too much time on upkeep. It’s also a good choice for bathrooms, kitchens, and other moisture-prone areas.
Hardwood floors are highly durable and come in many colors and styles, but they can get scratched or damaged by water. Although they cost more, with proper care, they can last a lifetime and raise your home’s value.
Back to Top