carpet flooring reviews

Carpet Flooring: Reviews, Best Brands & Pros vs. Cons

Last Updated on February 26, 2018

Which sounds better, walking across a soft, warm floor feeling the fibers of cozy carpet flooring against your bare feet, or stepping onto a cold, hard slab of tile?

While tile, hardwoods, and other flooring options do look nice, nothing feels as good as carpet.

Plus, carpet is pretty. And it hides dirt well.

So, if you don’t have a chance to clean the floors before your guests arrive, they’ll never notice. Unlike hardwood, where every particle of dust is visible, especially in sunlight.

If you are in the market for new flooring, there are many reasons you might want to consider carpet flooring for your home.

Carpet Flooring Pros

  1. Keeps rooms feeling warm & well-insulated.
  2. Softness is a plus for safety.
  3. Can be comfortable to walk and sit on.
  4. Absorbs sound and reduces noise.
  5. Huge range of styles, textures and colors.
  6. Appealing to the eye.

1. Carpet keeps rooms feeling warm and well-insulated.

Who wants to step barefoot onto a cold hard floor in the middle of winter?  No one.

Carpet not only feels warm to the touch, it helps keep rooms insulated. So, you can walk around without socks or slippers if you choose to.

And you won’t crank up the heater as much as you might with hard surface floors, like linoleum. So, your energy bill may also be less.

2. Because it is soft, carpeting is also safe.

Kids run through the house and can fall. Elderly people sometimes struggle to get around.

Carpet is a much safer option for both because you are less likely to fall on carpet than on other types of surfaces. And if you do, since it is soft, the impact will not be as harsh.

It is the best option when safety is a concern.

3. It is comfortable to walk or even sit on.

If you have an active family that likes to wrestle and play around, you need a comfortable floor. Rolling around on ceramic, porcelain tile, concrete, or hardwoods (or even softer woods, like cork or bamboo) is not fun.

However, carpet is cozy.

It feels good to walk on. And if you’d rather sit on the floor than a chair to watch television, you can do so with carpet.

4. Carpet absorbs sound and reduces noise.

Loud noises need a place to go. They reverberate off hard surfaces.

Carpet is absorbent. It can help stifle these sounds and reduce other noises.

So, if you like to walk around the house while others are sleeping, your footsteps won’t be heard nearly as much with carpet. In fact, your family might not be able to hear you at all.

5. There are so many choices of style, texture, and color.

Carpet comes in more options than any other type of flooring. Between colors, textures, styles, and thicknesses, the possibilities are virtually endless.

Looking for a plush, luxurious carpet for your bedroom?  You’ll have thousands of options to choose from.

Need a durable carpet for high traffic areas? There are countless varieties.

Even if you can narrow it down to Berber, frieze, loop, cut, or cut and loop, you’ll be able to find the look that is right for your budget and taste.

6. It is very appealing to look at.

Carpet is aesthetically appealing. It brings warmth and texture to any room.

And it makes people feel comfortable and cozy.

It also hides dirt well, unlike hard floors. So even if your carpet needs a good cleaning, your guests probably won’t be able to tell.

Back to Top

Carpet Flooring Cons

  1. Must be cleaned regularly.
  2. Can stain if you’re not careful.
  3. May cause health issues.
  4. If wet, may need to be removed.
  5. Not as durable as other flooring options.

1. It must be cleaned regularly.

Carpet flooring requires ongoing maintenance. It needs to be vacuumed regularly, or at the very least touched up with a carpet sweeper.

Periodic steam-cleaning is also recommended. You can hire a professional cleaning company, buy your own steam cleaner, or rent one at a local home improvement store.

While it may not always look like your carpet needs cleaning, you never know what all is lurking beneath its fibers.

2. It can stain if you are not careful.

Hopefully, the carpet you choose is treated with a stain guard. But even if it is treated, carpet can still stain.

There are many cleaning products that can remove most carpet stains; however, if it isn’t treated quickly, it is very difficult to remove a stain later. So, you may have to either learn to live with it or remove the stained carpet.

And some substances, such as red wine or pet urine, are very difficult to get out of carpet.

3. Carpet can cause health issues.

Carpet, like many other types of flooring, can give off chemical emissions. While it does not have the highest levels of VOCs compared to other flooring, this can be an issue for anyone who has health concerns.

It also tends to collect dust, dust mites, pet dander, and other allergens between the fibers. Anyone who needs to take measures to prevent allergens should consider an alternative to carpet.

However, if you or your family do not suffer from allergies, then regular carpet cleaning should suffice in keeping everyone happy and healthy.

4. If it gets wet, it may need to be removed.

Accidents happen. Water or juice spills on the floor, the hot water heater erupts, the dog has an accident or the house floods after a heavy rain.

Carpet does not hold up as well to water as other flooring. And in some of these cases, it may have to be removed altogether.

Liquids can seep down into the padding as well, causing the growth of mold and mildew.

So, if your home is vulnerable to any of these things, be prepared to replace the carpet periodically.

5. In general, it doesn’t last as long as other flooring options.

Some types of carpet are very durable; however, it is generally not as durable as other flooring options.

In areas with heavy traffic, some types of carpet can wear down quickly. Depending on your preferences, you may have to sacrifice style for durability.

While most come with 20+ year warranties, the average life expectancy of carpet is around 10 years.

So if you like the look and feel of carpet, keep in mind you may have to replace it regularly.

Back to Top

How to Find High Quality Carpet Flooring

With so many options and styles to choose from, what is most important in finding high quality carpet flooring?

First, look for a carpet that is safe and does not harm the quality of air in your home. Check to see what the manufacturer says about VOCs on their carpet or look for one with an eco-friendly label.

Also, find out what types of warranties are offered with the carpet you like. Look for guarantees against staining and a warranty that covers matting and crushing.

Use a reputable company that specializes in carpet and ask questions. A knowledgeable sales associate can share information with you on different fiber options so you can make an informed decision.

Even though there are many styles available, choose the one that best fits your needs. For example, if you’re carpeting a high-traffic area, Berber is a better choice than plush for that area.

The quality of padding and installation also play a role in the final product. Make sure to select a good-quality pad and use a qualified installer to put it in your home.

Back to Top

Carpet Flooring Cost

Depending on what style you choose and how much area is covered, carpet flooring can be very expensive or very inexpensive.

Here’s a breakdown of the costs by types of carpet flooring:

  • Loop Pile Carpet: This is a very durable carpet often used in commercial and high traffic areas. The price is dependent on the material used: Wool $10, Nylon $3, or Olefin $1.50 per square foot.
  • Cut Pile Carpet: The four categories of cut pile carpet are Saxony/plush, Textured Saxony, Frieze and Cable. Again, the material used impacts the average costs per square foot: Wool $15, Nylon $7.50, or Olefin $4.
  • Cut and Loop Carpet: This type is a combination of both the other styles. The average price is based on the type of material used: Wool $18.50, Nylon $10, or Olefin $6.50.

In addition to the cost of the carpet itself, there are also other expenses to factor into the total cost including:

  • Basic Installation: This averages $0.50 to $1 per square foot.
  • Additional installation fees: You’ll incur additional installation fees for things such as custom cuts for staircases and other tight areas, removal & replacement of baseboards, installing subfloors, adding molding, removing old flooring, and moving furniture. These fees generally cost an additional $0.50 to $2 per square foot.
  • Padding: Sometimes padding is included in the price of the carpet, but if it is not, it averages $0.30 to $0.60 per square foot.

These prices are estimates to give you an idea of the cost of carpet. However, the actual prices will vary based on where you live and what you choose.

Back to Top

Carpet Flooring Durability

The durability of carpet flooring is determined by primarily by three factors: fiber, twist, and density.

The types of carpet fiber include wool, nylon, acrylic, polyester, cotton and olefin.  The most durable fibers are ones that are wear-resistant and protect against dirt and stains.

The twist of the carpet has to do with how it is spun into yarn and how that yarn is twisted on itself. Generally speaking, the tighter the twist, the more durable the carpet.

Density refers to how much pile is in the carpet and how close together the tufts are. The most durable carpet floorings have a high density.

Back to Top

Carpet Flooring Reviews

American Carpet Wholesalers

For a huge selection of styles and brands at wholesale prices, American Carpet Wholesalers is the way to go. They offer carpet flooring from virtually every major carpet mill in the country.

They are a Fortune 5000 company and have even been featured on the Today Show for their selection and prices. And the company has received numerous rave reviews for their service and products.

Although you may save significantly on the cost of carpet, their store is in Dalton, GA. So, unless you live close by, you will have to order the carpet online.

And you will be responsible for finding and scheduling someone to install it for you. American Carpet Wholesalers will provide resources for this, but ultimately you must find someone yourself.

Empire Today

Empire Today offers all the major styles of carpet including plush, frieze, berber, patterned carpet, and even indoor/outdoor carpet. The company has received excellent reviews for its service, products, and installation.

When you order from Empire, you have the option to visit one of their many locations, or you can schedule for one of their sales associates to come to you.

The company has been in business for over 55 years and has successfully served over 2 million customers.

Home Depot

Home Depot is considered the top home improvement store in sales both online and at its many locations. The company makes it a priority to staff knowledgeable sales associates who can help customers make well-informed decisions.

Home Depot carries a large carpet selection ranging from low-end to high-quality carpet options. The company sells carpet from many of the major manufacturers.

The company often offers special carpet installation deals with a minimum purchase order. They have received mixed reviews by consumers for their flooring and installation.


Lowe’s carries many carpet options and is the only home improvement center that offers Stainmaster carpet. If you purchase their Stainmaster carpet, they also offer special deals on installation and removal of old carpet.

However, the company has received mixed reviews on their flooring installation.

Lowe’s has been around since the 1940s and is now the second-largest home improvement retailer in the world.

National Floors Direct

National Floors Direct carries many different carpet styles and brands from most of the leading carpet manufacturers. Although they operate primarily online, the company adds a personalized touch by offering free in-home appointments.

First, you complete an online form to schedule the appointment with a trained flooring specialist who then brings floor samples and assists you with the selection of your carpet.

National Floors Direct also offers next-day installation on all in-stock flooring. So, if you are anxious to get it installed, their service might be the best way to go.

Notable Mentions: Dream Weaver, DuPont, Fabrica, Kane, MohawkShaw Carpet, Tuftex

Back to Top

5 thoughts on “Carpet Flooring: Reviews, Best Brands & Pros vs. Cons”

  1. Avatar
    Cheryl Dansberger

    Don’t buy stainmaster carpet in the Baltimore area. You will never hear from the area rep when you have a stain problem and I have waited almost a year. What is the use of having a warranty when you can’t get your carpet taken care of when there is a problem? Buyer beware!

  2. Avatar


    We are just beginning our carpet search, and I agree with every point you make. We’ve compared Lowe’s and a local store that carries many name brand carpets, and honestly felt Lowe’s gave us more options and took the time to explain the differences. Stainmaster carpets offer a nice variety of options (nylon, polyester, pet protections, etc) with a variety of pricing which allows you some flexibility with your budget.

    Their installation package that includes moving furniture and hauling away the old carpet (standard for most sellers) add a little incentive for us too. I found them to be very helpful with questions and we learned a lot. We have one more place we’ll check, but based on experience thus far I’d consider Lowe’s. Just my opinion!

  3. Avatar
    Kristin Christopherson

    I can’t find any reference to quality carpet brands in this piece or on the site. You have excellent information on all other types of flooring but lets be honest, if you live somewhere cold 9 months of the year most people want some rooms laid with carpet. The quality of your carpet makes a big difference in a homeowner’s overall happiness. Especially if you have kids, pets or work at home which more and more people are doing these days. I have all three of these factors and want to purchase the best quality carpet I can afford. People like me need Carpet that can be cleaned easily and frequently, that effectively resists stains and wear patterns, is well cushioned and has a nice feel. Also it needs to be super low on health and environmental nasties. Advice appreciated!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *