fbpx
best outdoor door mat

5 Best Outside Door Mats: Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

May 31, 2021 / 0 Comments

Are you struggling and frustrated with the floor buying process?
Let us help by connecting with one our certified Floor Critic Experts!
  • Understand the difference between value, durability and great looking flooring.
  • Learn which types of flooring will increase the value of your home.
  • We‘ll show you which flooring has amazing prices and ease of installation.

Our expert editors independently review, test, and recommend products to help you make an informed decision. We may earn commissions on purchases made from our product links.

The doormat is one of the first things people will notice about your house. So, why not find one that will leave a strong impression and trap all the dirt before it enters your home? After reading this review, I’m pretty sure you’ll find the best outdoor door mat.

When looking for a good front door mat, you should opt for a material that captures debris that is easy to clean and lasts a long time. If you don’t know which fabric and features to look for, keep on reading to check out my buyer’s guide.

Below you’ll also find the five best mats that I reviewed and compared in detail, with all the pros, cons, and features.

Spoiler alert! The Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir Front Door Welcome Mat is an absolute pleasure to look at and use. This product includes two mats: one coir and one cotton rug. It’s the most durable mat that I’ve ever had and captures most of the dirt and debris.

I found it very simple to clean, non-slippery, and perfect for any season. This product comes with a 10-year warranty, so you can already tell that it’s worth every penny.

5 Best Outside Door Mats

  PRODUCT  
Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir Front Door Welcome Mat
  • Size: 30” x 17.5” x 0.6” for the mat, 36” x 24” for the buffalo plaid rug
  • Material: 100% pure coco coir for the mat, 100% cotton material for the rug
  • Non-slippery PVC base
  • Weight: 60.1 lbs.

 

View On Amazon →Check Our Review
DII Heavy Duty Natural Rubber Doormat
  • Available in three sizes: 18” x 30”, 24” x 36”, 30” x 48”
  • Comes in 19 different variations (shapes and colors)
  • Made of durable rubber material (60% rubber, 40% coir)
  • PVC backing
  • Weight: 5 lbs.

 

View On Amazon →Check Our Review
Gorilla Grip Original Durable Natural Rubber Door Mat
  • Available in six sizes: 17” x 24”, 20” x 32”, 39” x 20”, 48” x 20”, 60” x 20, 70” x 24”
  • Comes in 13 different colors and patterns
  • 100% natural rubber border and high-quality woven polypropylene fabric in the middle
  • Weight: 2.29 lbs.

 

View On Amazon →Check Our Review
Sierra Concepts 2-Pack Striped Door Floor Mat
  • Size: 30” x 17”
  • Available in five colors
  • Two pieces in the package
  • Polyester and polyvinyl chloride material
  • Weight: 4.2 lbs.

 

View On Amazon →Check Our Review
Apache Mills Masterpiece Flagstone Grey Stone Door Mat
  • Available in two sizes:18” x 30”, 22” x 36”
  • Comes in 11 gorgeous, striking prints
  • Made of synthetic material
  • Weight: 5 lb.

 

View On Amazon →Check Our Review

Best Outside Door Mats – Reviews

Best Overall: Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir Front Door Welcome Mat

Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir Front Door Welcome Mat


On my journey to find the best doormat for an outdoor space, I encountered the gorgeous Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir mat. This is one of the cutest mat designs that are extremely durable, lasting for many years, and will enhance the look of every front door.

The stunning set of two mats will elevate the appearance of your porch. The mat is made of 100% pure coconut coir material and features a “Home Sweet Home” saying on it. The buffalo rug has a black and white plaid print and is made of 100% cotton material.

Key Features
  • Size: 30” x 17.5” x 0.6” for the mat, 36” x 24” for the buffalo plaid rug
  • Material: 100% pure coco coir for the mat, 100% cotton material for the rug
  • Non-slippery PVC base
  • Weight: 60.1 lbs.

Maintenance is straightforward; just shake and beat to remove dirt and dust. It’s one of the more expensive alternatives on the list, but don’t forget that you get two mats. Plus, the coir mat can last for a decade; consider this as a long-term investment.

It’s the most durable mat I’ve tried. It doesn’t show any color or shape changes, and I’ve been using it for months. The surface of the coir mat is textured and grabs on dirt very well.

The PVC base of the mat can be damaged by constant rain exposure, so if you notice that it’s raining right over the mat, you should consider a new spot. Another thing to keep in mind is that the cotton sheet is not waterproof and should be kept away from water.

Pros
  • Thick coir material that provides excellent comfort
  • Successfully captures dirt, dust, grass
  • It has a non-slip PVC base to keep it in place
  • Gorgeous appearance
  • Two-in-one design
  • 10-year no-questions-asked policy for returns
Cons
  • You should avoid placing it on direct rain
  • The cotton buffalo sheet is not waterproof

This is the most aesthetically pleasing mat on the list and includes two pieces for the price of one. Everyone who loves a good-looking mat for their front door should opt for this one. The durability is unmatched; the material is thick, high-quality, and great for high-traffic areas.

  • Non-slippery: Yes
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Does it collect water: No

Back To Top

Best Heavy Duty: DII Heavy Duty Natural Rubber Doormat

DII Heavy Duty Natural Rubber Doormat


The DII Heavy Duty Natural Rubber doormat is my second favorite product in this category. Aside from featuring a reasonable price, the mat has lots of different variations that look great.

For everyone who needs a rubber mat with a unique appearance, this durable rubber design is as striking as it gets. It comes in 19 designs and three different sizes. The PVC backing will keep it in place and prevent it from moving.

Key Features
  • Available in three sizes: 18” x 30”, 24” x 36”, 30” x 48”
  • Weight: 5 lbs.
  • Comes in 19 different variations (shapes and colors)
  • Made of durable rubber material (60% rubber, 40% coir)
  • PVC backing

The maintenance is simple; just shake the mat to get rid of dirt. You can also wash it with water when needed. It dries out very fast. It’s safe to say that this is a reasonably priced product considering all the benefits it offers.

The DII Heavy Duty design is one of the most durable mats I’ve tested. It exceeded my expectations in terms of longevity. I placed it in a high-traffic area, but I didn’t notice any changes in the shape or color.

The surface of this outdoor door mat depends on the design. The designs without holes capture dirt and dust very well.

Pros
  • Captures a lot of dirt and dust to prevent it from entering your home
  • It’s quite durable
  • It’s straightforward to clean
  • You can use it in various areas, including the garage, patio, front door, laundry room, garden
  • It’s heavy-duty and can withstand a lot of traffic
  • It has a PVC base to prevent slipping
  • Doesn’t collect water because it runs through the holes
Cons
  • Can slightly change shape in extreme climate changes
  • Dirt can sometimes fall through some of the designs

This is a lightweight mat that is very easy to shake and clean. It doesn’t collect water but captures dirt, dust, and grass. It’s the mat with the most diverse designs on this list.

  • Non-slippery: Yes
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Does it collect water: No

Back To Top

Best Color And Size Selection: Gorilla Grip Original Durable Natural Rubber Door Mat

Gorilla Grip Original Durable Natural Rubber Door Mat


The Gorilla Grip Original Rubber mat will soon become one of your favorite mats. Thanks to the variety of colors and sizes, you can adapt the design to your needs.

This is one of the most versatile products on the list with six sizes and 13 gorgeous prints and colors. The mat’s border is made of high-quality 100% natural rubber and the middle part is made of woven polypropylene. The backing is also made of natural rubber.

Key Features
  • Available in six sizes: 17” x 24”, 20” x 32”, 39” x 20”, 48” x 20”, 60” x 20, 70” x 24”
  • Comes in 13 different colors and patterns
  • 100% natural rubber border and high-quality woven polypropylene fabric in the middle
  • Weight: 2.29 lbs.

Maintenance is simple; beating and shaking will remove most of the dirt. You can also use a broom to clean the rug. Don’t forget to let it dry completely when it’s wet.

The price of the Gorilla Grip mat is somewhere on the lower end of the price scale and an excellent match to the mat’s performance. This product is not as durable as my top pick, but it will still last you a few years.

The surface of the mat is textured and absorbs dust, dirt, and water. One of the downsides of this mat is that it absorbs moisture, but it dries relatively fast in most cases. If the weather is cold and humid, it will take longer for the mat to dry.

Pros
  • It traps dirt, dust, debris and prevents them from getting into your home
  • It’s great for indoor and outdoor use
  • Very durable material that doesn’t damage
  • Non-slippery base to keep it put into place
Cons
  • It absorbs moisture, so it might take some time for the mat to be dry
  • It can be a breeding ground for mold and mildew if not dried properly

This is the product that has the widest selection of colors and sizes. Aside from that, it’s pretty durable but tends to absorb water.

  • Non-slippery: Yes
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Does it collect water: Yes

Back To Top

Best Budget: Sierra Concepts 2-Pack Striped Door Floor Mat

Sierra Concepts 2-Pack Striped Door Floor Mat


The Sierra is the best budget product and includes two identical mats in the packaging.

The pack comes in five pretty colors and is made of high-quality polyester and polyvinyl material. The surface of the fabric is textured to capture dirt before it enters your home. It has a rubber backing to prevent slipping.

Key Features
  • Size: 30” x 17”
  • Available in five colors
  • Two pieces in the package
  • Polyester and polyvinyl chloride material
  • Weight: 4.2lbs.

For maintenance, you’ll need to beat the mats and use a broom or a vacuum. Also, this is the most affordable product in this guide, making it a perfect buy for everyone with a limited budget.

Although this is an inexpensive purchase, the quality and durability are high. It features a textured surface that traps dirt, dust, and debris. Thankfully, it doesn’t absorb water to keep your porch and front door area dry.

After placing this mat in a high-frequency area, I noticed that the surface started becoming flat. It’s best to use it for a front door with low traffic, basements, and patios.

Pros
  • Most affordable purchase on the list
  • Two mats for the price of one
  • Recycled rubber and high-quality polyester materials
  • It has a non-slip backing to keep it in place
Cons
  • The surface can become flat after some time
  • It’s not suitable for high-frequency areas

As I mentioned, this is the cheapest product among the five, but it’s quite durable and easy to maintain. The five colors are all gorgeous and will be a great addition to your front door.

  • Non-slippery: Yes
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Does it collect water: No

Back To Top

Most Innovative Design: Apache Mills Masterpiece Flagstone Grey Stone Door Mat

Apache Mills Masterpiece Flagstone Grey Stone Door Mat


The Apache Mills Masterpiece mat is my go to when I want to upgrade my front door’s appearance with a unique design.

These mats are made of recycled rubber from old scrap tires. It’s an eco-friendly purchase for everyone who prefers more sustainable material alternatives. You’ll find it in two sizes and 11 fun designs.

Key Features
  • Available in two sizes:18” x 30”, 22” x 36”
  • Comes in 11 gorgeous, striking prints
  • Made of synthetic material
  • Weight: 5lb.

Just like the rest of the products I reviewed, this mat is simple to clean. It doesn’t absorb water, and it dries very quickly. The price is more affordable than the previous mats, but it’s also a lower quality product.

If you want to purchase one of these pretty mats, place it somewhere with low to medium traffic. I noticed that it can get flat after continuous use in high-traffic spots, so it’s more suitable for a lower-activity area of your home.

Pros
  • Made of recycled rubber from old tires
  • Made in the USA
  • The prints of the mat are unique and eye-catching
  • Collects dirt, dust but doesn’t absorb water
  • It’s not slippery
Cons
  • The quality of this product is not as high as for the other mats
  • Not great for heavy-traffic areas

Although the quality of this mat comes close to the previous options, it’s still a little less durable. The material started to show changes sooner, that’s why it’s more suitable for low-traffic areas.

  • Non-slippery: Yes
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Does it collect water: No

Buyer’s Guide

When shopping for an outdoor mat, these are some of the features to keep in mind:

Size

The size of your doormat should be as wide as your door or at least take over 80% of your front door’s width. There is no rule when it comes to the size; however, it should be big enough to grab all the dirt and dust and fit your feet. After testing so many mats, I learned that bigger sizes work better and are more useful.

Back To Top

Material

Some of the most common mat materials are rubber, vinyl, coir, synthetic. Each material has its pros and cons; the choice mainly depends on what you’re looking for.

Coir mats look great, capture a lot of dirt, and are durable. One of the cons is that the material can shed and get inside your home.

Rubber mats are also highly durable and most commonly found in front of doors. They are good at trapping dirt but aren’t always aesthetically pleasing.

Synthetic mats are usually made of rubber and polypropylene. These are great at collecting dirt and water, and they are easy to clean. They aren’t the prettiest mats but are perfect for an outdoor space.

Back To Top

Surface

The surface of an outdoor mat should be textured to grab dirt. Flat surfaces aren’t as successful at gathering debris, so you should stick to a mat with a rough, abrasive surface.

Back To Top

FAQs

How Long Do Coir Mats Last?

Coir is one of the eco-friendliest materials for mats. It’s a sustainable choice that many people love, plus it looks great. The average life of a coir mat is between 6 and 10 years.


How Do You Clean Outside Door Mats?

The cleaning process is pretty much the same, no matter the material. You should start by beating and shaking the rug to get rid of all the debris and dirt.

Next, you can use water and soap to clean the mat further. Don’t forget to rinse it well with water.

Let the mat dry completely, and you’re ready to go! As you can see, the process is so simple and works for most materials. Using a brush to scrub off dirt can work great for rubber mats, while it might not be the best idea for coir mats.

If the manufacturer suggests that you clean the mat differently, follow their instructions.

Conclusion

After learning about these five mats, do you have a favorite? Ensure that the mat you choose is made of high-quality fabric, traps dirt and debris, is waterproof, and easy to clean.

The Sierra Concepts Pure Coco Coir Front Door Welcome Mat is a fantastic purchase because it will last you for years and it’s one of the prettiest mats. It’s heavy, but it’s great for heavy traffic areas. Thanks to the non-slippery nature of the product, it will stay put and improve the appearance of your front door, patio, garage, and more.

If you have any comments or first-hand experiences with these mats, please post them below or share your pictures via our social media.

About Maricel Dee

Maricel Dee is a writer & blogger on all things home improvement. When she's not writing on her favorite home improvement topics, you can find her immersed in her own home projects.

Back to Top

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *